Bendel and unpaid trust distributions: what the High Court changed

By Anthony Pratt, CA CTA · 4 min read

The High Court has confirmed that a company's unpaid entitlement to trust income is not, by itself, a loan for Division 7A purposes. The decision removes a long-running compliance burden for many family groups, but it does not switch off every integrity rule.


Key takeaways

  • In Commissioner of Taxation v Bendel [2026] HCA 18, the High Court held that a company doing nothing about an unpaid entitlement does not make a Division 7A loan.
  • The ATO has accepted the decision and will withdraw TD 2022/11. Existing written loan agreements still need their minimum yearly repayments.
  • Subdivision EA and section 100A can still apply, depending on how the funds are used.

The arrangement at the centre of the case

A familiar pattern in private groups runs like this. A discretionary trust carries on the business. Each year the trustee resolves to distribute part of the income to a company in the same group. The company pays tax at the corporate rate, but the cash stays in the trust as working capital. The company's right to that money is an unpaid present entitlement, or UPE.

For more than a decade the ATO treated that UPE as a loan by the company to the trust once the company knew of it and did not call for payment. On that view, Division 7A applied, so groups had to put the UPE on complying loan terms, charge the benchmark interest rate and make minimum yearly repayments, or face a deemed unfranked dividend.

What the High Court decided

In Commissioner of Taxation v Bendel [2026] HCA 18, handed down in June 2026, the majority rejected that view. Their reasoning was straightforward. A loan, including the extended idea of providing financial accommodation, requires the company to do something. A company that simply leaves its entitlement unpaid has not advanced money, provided accommodation or entered a transaction. Inaction is not a loan.

The majority also pointed to the structure of Division 7A itself. Parliament dealt with unpaid entitlements in a separate set of rules, Subdivision EA, rather than through the definition of a loan.

How the ATO has responded

The ATO published a decision impact statement in late June 2026. It accepts that no Division 7A loan arises where a corporate beneficiary takes no action on its entitlement, and it will withdraw Taxation Determination TD 2022/11, which set out the earlier view. Our Division 7A guide for 2026–27 reflects the updated position.

Two points in the ATO's response matter in practice.

Existing loan agreements stand

Where a group put a written Division 7A loan agreement in place to deal with a UPE under the old view, that agreement does not fall away because of Bendel. Minimum yearly repayments are still required for the rest of the loan term, or until the loan is repaid, to avoid a deemed dividend.

Other rules still apply

Subdivision EA can still deem a dividend where the trust uses the unpaid funds to pay, lend to, or forgive a debt of a shareholder of the company or their associate. Section 100A can still apply where an entitlement arises under a reimbursement agreement, with the trustee taxed at the top rate.

Bendel answered one question clearly. It did not answer every question about unpaid entitlements.

What may change next

The ATO has said it is reviewing its guidance and may issue more. Treasury's consultation on the proposed 30 per cent minimum tax also floated changes that would bring unpaid distributions back within Division 7A. That is not law, but it means planning built on Bendel alone may need revisiting before 1 July 2028.

A practical review

For groups with a corporate beneficiary, now is a sensible time to:

  • List every UPE owed to a company in the group, by year and amount.
  • Separate UPEs covered by existing loan agreements from those that are not, and keep up repayments on the former.
  • Check whether any trust funds have been paid or lent to shareholders or their associates.
  • Confirm that distribution resolutions, minutes and ledgers record what actually happened.
  • Consider whether earlier years' positions justify an amendment or objection, within time limits.

The outcome turns on the trust deed, the resolutions and how the money moved, so it is worth reviewing case by case rather than assuming. This forms part of our Division 7A advice for private companies and the family business accountants work we do in Sydney and on the Gold Coast.

This article is general information only, current as at 21 November 2026. It is not accounting, tax or financial-product advice for your particular situation, and you should obtain advice before acting on it. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Previous
Previous

The 2026–27 Federal Budget tax reforms: where each measure stands

Next
Next

Family trusts and the proposed 30 per cent minimum tax: the planning choices